Week 9 War Room November 4, 2012  |  Jeff

Get out your calculator. Don’t worry, you don’t necessarily need your confusing graphing calculator from calculus class, just the calculator on your phone will suffice. Ok, the fantasy season is 16 weeks long, week 1 through league championship week. Take those 16 weeks and divide them by 2, and we can deduce that we are smack dab in the middle of our 2012 fake football odyssey. Just a few regular season weeks and a few measly playoffs games stand between us and our own fantasy championship parade. With wins at a premium, each week is of the utmost importance. Make sure you are maximizing your lineup for week 9, by digging into The Fake Footballs’ Week 9 War Room below…




– If the world of weekly fantasy games is up your alley, take a peak at our Week 9 Fanduel Bargains to make sure your lineup is loaded and ready to bring you bags full of dough.

– Once again here to dig into the latest and greatest injury news and timeshare breakdowns is our week 9 Last Second Decisions column, which is a fantasy treasure chest of information.

– If critical start/sit decisions are plaguing your week 9 lineup, check out The Fake Football’s Week 9 Start/Sit column to find out who should be benched and who will flourish this Sunday.

– As fantasy games gain significance in the latter stages of the season, defensive matchups mean more than ever. Find out which D’s are prime for playing in week 9 with this week’s “Dreaming of Streaming.”

– In the stats department, The Fake Football has everything you need to become the local wizard of statistical strategery. Rest of season strength of schedule is covered HERE, Week 9 matchup stats are HERE, and a full breakdown of week 8’s receiving targets is located in THIS GENERAL REGION. Enjoy.


Finally, for your enjoyment, are the Week 9 Staff Rankings from The Fake Football crew. Feel free to leave those lineups questions in the comment below and get ready to dominate in week 9!

2012 Fantasy Football Rankings powered by FantasyPros

133 Responses

  1. Norman says:

    14 Team PPR: My current RBs are Martin, Alex Green, Kendall Hunter & Andre Brown. Players only go on waivers when they are dropped. Do you think it’s worth it to scoop up Marcel Reece right now? If so, which rb would you drop?

    • Jeff says:

      Thats a tough call with Goodson’s status up in the air still. I guess I would say Green or Hunter for the drop but they are all so close. Hunter has better upside, so I guess dump Green as Starks is taking some of his work now anyway. This is still a risky proposition with Goodson’s injury unknown.

  2. y4rivera says:

    I was offered two offers by the same owner.

    1st: My Lynch and Cobb for Charles and Gore.
    2nd: My Lynch for Charles and McGahee
    starting rosters: qb, rb, rb, wr, wr, w/r/t
    My Team
    RG3, Stafford
    Lynch, DMC, Murray, Pierre, D.Rich, Dwyer
    Wallace, Jordy, Cobb, Hartline, Britt
    With the injuries to Murray and DMC I’m really tempted. I also feel it’s the best time to sell Cobb especially since I only start two WR’s. Which one if any should I do?

    • Jeff says:

      I would hold onto Cobb, especially with Nelson banged up. I wouldn’t really argue with deal #2 if you wanted to pursue that, although Murray should be back next week.

  3. Blanket says:

    2 things:

    1) Thoughts about J-Stew moving forward?
    2) Time to get rid of Vikings D?

    • Jeff says:

      I think J-Stew will be ok going forward, but 9 carry 37 yard games will happen along the way. I am more of a D streamer, so I think you can definitely move on from Minnesota and survive.

  4. Norman says:

    10 Team PPR: Eli, Cruz, Marshall, Wayne, Rice, AP, DMC, Gates. Bench: Dez, Bell, Vernon, Luck, Amendola, Beanie, Hanson, Hou. In 1st place right now, looking to make 1 more trade to keep my team strong. I was thinking about trying to trade Luck, DMC &/or Amendola. What kind of trade would you recommend I go for?

    • Jeff says:

      Well it looks like you won’t get anything for DMC now after the injury, but you may be able to attempt a trade involving Luck to get you a DMC replacement if that is something you’re looking for. No sense in holding both Eli and Luck.

  5. Jeff says:


  6. y4rivera says:

    pick 2: Jordy, Cobb, Pierre

  7. alexsyntex says:

    D Brown or Ballard?

  8. Mike says:

    standard league question: antonio brown, daniel thomas or vick ballard for flex. thanks!

  9. FreeDiro says:

    Kendall Wright or Andre Brown for a flex spot?

  10. alexsyntex says:

    PR need 2. JNelson, Nate Washington or Golden Tate

  11. joshco77 says:

    Tony Gonzo or LeShoure at flex? PPR for WR/TE, not for RB. 10 pt rushing TD/7 pt receiving. Thanks!

  12. Jim Parkey says:

    Pick 1 for flex (non-ppr): Dez, Hartline, Felix Jones

  13. AdamH says:

    Antonio brown our Pierre Thomas in 0.5 ppr?

  14. bushi says:

    With Nelson playing how does Cobb look over guys like Maclin, Moore, and Harvin?

  15. Play Aldrick Robinson over Dez or handcuff Dez with either Ingram or Devery Henderson?

  16. Bryan says:

    Different League.
    I can Flex Josh Freeman or Mikel Leshoure. Its a PPR, QBs get 6 per TD but only 50yds per point.

  17. Lou says:

    do I start Nelson over Moore, Maclin, or Wallace or no?

  18. san says:

    Non PPR. LSH v. Shorts? Thanks!

  19. Nick says:

    Pick two: D. Moore, Cobb, S. Smith, or J. Jones at WR. Pick two at RB: McFadden, R. Bush, Spiller or J. Stewart? Thanks.

  20. Cory says:

    Good morning,

    1PPR – Pick 3

    Julio Jones, Roddy White, Jeremy Maclin, Brandon Marshall.


  21. doc says:

    Gimme 2: Calvin colston torrey or dhb. Need 1: Daniel Thomas or BGE. 12 team standard

  22. Blanket says:

    better flex? Denarius Moore or J-Stew?

  23. Adam says:

    James jones or Calvin today?

    • Jeff says:

      It’s a bit of a roll of the dice with Megatron but I trust him as long as he’s active, which he is. Jones may be safer, but I would gamble on ‘Tron.

  24. Bryan says:

    I have Dez Bryant, Cecil Shorts, and Lance Moore. I can start 1 and Flex 1. Should I just bench Dez and be done with it? or hold out Moore in case Dez plays? PPR

    • Jeff says:

      I wouldYa, I would just bench Dez and be done with it. I dooubt he plays and the other guys are decent options compared to a limited Dez anyhow.

  25. gerbz says:

    Cobb v. Decker in a PPR? Thanks.

  26. Brad Graham says:

    Luck or Romo? Dez, Antonio Brown, or Titus?

  27. Trade advice? says:

    i just made this trade – tell me if im crazy or if im a genius…
    i gave up Murray, Antonio Brown, and Keller for Julio Jones and Amendola
    My current RBs are: Rice, Trent, Murray, J-Stew, M. Bush
    My current WRs are: Marshall, Denarius, Antonio Brown, Britt
    My starting TE is Hernandez

    need reassurance.

  28. Charlie says:

    Reaching really deep need 2 of Hillman, Turbin, Forsett, Rainey

  29. Ruxin says:

    I need 2 WR and 1 Flex in PPR:
    A. Johnson, Cobb, Maclin, T. Young…C. Spiller, M. Leshoure

  30. Shane says:

    I have A. Rodgers, do I go with James Jones or Broyles? 1/2 point ppr

  31. Andrew says:

    Donald Brown or James Starks? 0.5 PPR.

  32. B.o.B says:

    Who’s the best play at Flex? Daniel Thomas @ Indy, Sidney Rice vs. Minn, Alex Green vs. Ari or Vick Ballard vs. Mia…

  33. Trade advice? says:

    hey guys i just made this trade – tell me if im crazy or if im a genius…

    i gave up Murray, Antonio Brown, and Keller for Julio Jones and Amendola

    My current RBs are: Rice, Trent, Murray, J-Stew, M. Bush
    My current WRs are: Marshall, Denarius, Antonio Brown, Britt
    My starting TE is Hernandez

    thanks guys. love all your advice!

  34. Jordan says:

    Trade offered to me: Colston & F-Jax for R.Bush & H.Miller. Standard scoring. Thoughts?

    Current WRs: Jordy, Miles, Bowe, Boldin
    Current RBs: AP, Mathews, R.Bush, R.Jennings
    Current TEs: TonyG, Heath

  35. allballs says:

    non ppr, would you start Hartline over Dez with his late game + questionable tag? Or should I pick up and play Titus Young (I’d be dropping deangelo williams) thanks chet

  36. Ryan says:

    Jordy or Britt – help!

  37. Jordan says:

    Jordy (reports saying he is active) or Boldin. Standard scoring.

  38. Stephen says:


  39. zajb says:

    1pt PPR – Denarius Moore or Titus Young?


  40. Keir says:

    PPR. Need 2nd RB. Ballard or A. Brown?

  41. Marrett says:

    Start Titus Young over Dez? non ppr. WR3 spot. thanks

  42. keith says:

    P. Manning or M. Vick?

  43. Bruh says:

    Nonppr Pick 3: DMC, Spiller, Pierre Thomas, Rashad Jennings

  44. any thoughts on starting 2 of the following: Non-PPR
    McFadden, Pettigrew, Nicks and Steve Smith.

  45. Anthony says:

    Pick 2 (.5 PPR): B. Marsh, Andre Johnson, and Denarius Moore.

  46. Anthony says:

    Pick 2 (.5 PPR): Larry Fitz, Andre Johnson, and Miles Austin.

  47. ViolentMike says:

    Who you starting in flex today (ppr) – CJ Spiller against the Texans or Broyles against Jax with Megatron banged up?

    • C.D. Carter says:

      You have to roll with Spiller. He’s averaging more than seven yards a touch. You can’t afford to bench him.

  48. Brandon says:

    Yo CD. I was offered 2 trades for my Murray
    1) Decker and Dez for Murray.
    2) Julio Jones for Murray and Antonio Brown
    Which one should I accept, if either?
    My current RBs are: Rice, Trent, Murray, J-Stew, M. Bush
    My current WRs are: Marshall, Denarius, Antonio Brown, Britt
    Please let me know ASAP!! Thanks.

    • C.D. Carter says:

      1) I’d take that deal in a hurry.
      2) I’d rather have Julio than Brown and Murray.
      Godspeed, fantasy fiend.

      • Brandon says:

        HA! wait so r u saying in should take deal 1 or deal 2? I can only accept one of them ;-)

        • C.D. Carter says:

          Oh, I see. I’d go with the second deal.

          • Brandon says:

            r u 100% sure? Even given my current RBs and WRs? thanks for the help man, im a very reluctant trader haha

          • C.D. Carter says:

            It might not be terrible to have patience and wait for DeMarco to get back to full health. Your WR depth seems fine. But I think if you can ever get Julio, you pull the proverbial trigger.

  49. W.C. says:

    For ppr flex do I go with Gordon, Broyles, or Boldin. My gut says Gordon.

  50. Colin says:

    Maclin or Decker in a 0.5 ppr?

  51. Sven says:

    Bought low on Calvin this week, Love the match-up for Calvin this week. However, really not loving the knee situation, not practicing all week, or game-time decision this week.

    Normally, it’s blasphemy to sit a stud if he starts, but given the circumstances and the fact that he might be used on a limited basis on 3rd downs, do i SIT Calvin?

    If yes, do I start James Jones (and is that contingent on Nelson not playing?) or Lance Moore?

    • C.D. Carter says:

      Lions’ beat writers are saying (at 10:22 a.m.) that Megatron is not on the field for pregame warmups. This, they say, is unusual. Keep tabs on the situation, and if he sits, play Jones.

  52. Spen says:

    Donnie Avery or Louis Murphy flex?

  53. TheRealTaz says:

    PPR question:

    With Donald Brown unlikely to play, is Vick Ballard is a better flex option than any of:

    Titus Young
    Torrey Smith
    Julio Jones (I know, never bench studs, but he’s playing a top pass D and Atlanta’s passing game is unpredictable…)


    • C.D. Carter says:

      It’s not just “Don’t bench your studs” in Julio’s case. He’s more talented and more opportunity than any other guy on this short list. He’s not going to post 100 yards and a score every week, but I think if we temper expectations a bit, Julio’s a no-brainer plug and play.

  54. Jeff says:

    What are your thoughts on Aaron Hernandez for the rest of the year? Is it just a matter of time or will he be risky for the seasons duration?

  55. Matt says:

    Torrey Smith or Titus Young? Also, pick 2: Spiller, F. Jax or Redman?

    • C.D. Carter says:

      Go Titus. Really hate to roll with two RBs from the same backfield, but I hate Redman today. If you must bench one Bills’ RB, bench Jackson.

  56. Jake says:

    If Brown is really out today (which I am assuming is not accounted for in your current rankings), would you start Ballard over Josh Gordon (who is currently in my Flex), Leshoure, or CJ2k (who are my starting RBs)? Yes, I know this is ugly…

    • C.D. Carter says:

      I would start Gordon there. Probably he’ll need a bomb to reach WR1/2 status, but he’ll get his chances against a 24th-ranked Ravens pass defense.

  57. Jeff says:

    How concerned should I be with my quality of RB’s? I have Charles, Dmc, Matthews, McGahee & S-Jax.

    • C.D. Carter says:

      I’m not all that worried about Jamaal. He’s showing unreal lateral agility, he’s still getting a nice workload, and he was *this close* to breaking a 90-yard run against San Diego this week. Don’t panic.
      DMC, I think, has to be considered a top-15 RB for the rest of the season. The Raiders’ offensive line is truly awful, and it won’t get much better. DMC, like Foster and Rice, has unquestioned job stability.
      It’s clear that Mathews isn’t going to get 25 carries a game. I’d wait until he goes bananas and trade him for WR depth, if you need it.

  58. Simon says:

    2 Q’s PPR LG Fred Jackson vs Hou or Josh Gordon vs Bal and Freeman vs Oak or Luck vs Mia?

  59. Johnnystickman says:

    1ppr. Safe to Get rid of Dwyer bc I have Mendy? Redman available. But in PPR I need Andre Roberts, S Moss or S Rice?

  60. Stephen says:

    Weedon or Wilson?

  61. David White says:

    If Calvin sits, Titus Young or Cobb non-PPR?

  62. Glenn says:

    1 pt PPR, V Jackson or James Jones? Thank you!

    • C.D. Carter says:

      I wouldn’t be put off by last week’s VJax bomb. He’s still one of the most heavily targeted pass catcher in the NFL, and he plays today against an exploitable Raiders’ secondary.

  63. Dan says:

    Is Calvin johnson’s knee concerning enough to bench him for lance Moore in a PPR league?

    • C.D. Carter says:

      It’s impossible to bench Megatron if he plays. Keep up to date on his status and play Moore if he’s out. With Sproles out, Moore could see another 3-5 targets a game from here on out.

Leave a Reply


The Fake Football DFS Reader Leagues – Week 17 and Full Season Results!

After a long, hard-fought 17 weeks of competition, we are pleased to announce that the winner of the 2017 Fake Football DFS Reader League is FanDuel user and Fake Football reader ejbelair!!! ejbelair scored 2,073.48 points throughout the season, an incredible average of 121.97 points per week and a whopping 92.48 more ...


The Fake Football DFS Reader Leagues – Week 16 Results

Week 16 is in the books, and FanDuel user and Fake Football reader ejbelair came out on top to win a stylish Fake Football t-shirt! ejbelair is also on the way towards winning a six-month premium subscription to FantasyPros! AND this trophy from FantasyTrophies.com!     With a score of 158.28, ejbelair utilized high ...


The Fake Football DFS Reader Leagues – Weeks 14 & 15 Results

Weeks 13 and 14 are in the books, and FanDuel users and Fake Football readers mrkreen and jaybass came out on top to win stylish Fake Football t-shirts! They are also on the way towards winning a six-month premium subscription to FantasyPros! AND this trophy from FantasyTrophies.com!     With a score of 171.84, mrkreen utilized high ...