Toby Gerhart: Brute Force March 18, 2014  |  Nathan Miller

Last week, dynasty league managers popped a cork and celebrated the start of the 2014 season with the opening of free agency. The event breaks the doldrums of the offseason and leads into a wave of NFL happenings. One acquisition that intrigued me more than most was the Jacksonville Jaguars signing of Toby Gerhart.

Gerhart, the four year back-up to future Hall-of-Famer Adrian Peterson, has seen minimal work since entering the NFL. He carries with him a stunning statistical past, minimal tread on a 26 year-old frame, and extensive experience working under one of the best in the league. But as with any free agency move, many times the excitement of NFL related action clouds a manager’s judgment. Much like a Dustin Diamond show at your local night club, it’s intriguing, but is it worth the money?

Gerhart’s collegiate career was nothing short of impressive. After missing his first starting season to a knee injury, Gerhart went on to rush for over 1100 yards and 15 scores in 2008, and followed that up his senior year with nearly 1900 yards and a mind-boggling 28 touchdowns. His success led to a Heisman nomination, to which he finished second in voting to Mark Ingram (sad, I know).

Year G Att Yds Avg TD Rec Yds Avg TD Plays Yds Avg TD
2006 12 106 375 3.5 0 15 124 8.3 0 121 499 4.1 0
2007 1 12 140 11.7 1 0 12 140 11.7 1
2008 12 210 1136 5.4 15 13 114 8.8 0 223 1250 5.6 15
*2009 13 343 1871 5.5 28 11 157 14.3 0 354 2028 5.7 28
Career 671 3522 5.2 44 39 395 10.1 0 710 3917 5.5 44


First impressions of Gerhart often include his size. As refresher, Toby Gerhart is a big dude. Not “Beep, beep, back-up-the-bus” big, but “Dude, playa don’t play” big. His size can lead misconceptions of slow moving objects that make deliberately wide turns, but this is not the case with Gerhart. Draftniks describe his prowess as vision, lateral agility, power, soft hands, swashbuckling (disclaimer: may not be a real thing), etc. Gerhart’s a talent on the field, and has the size to facilitate his success. A brief look back on combine scores (notably, 40s) revealed some alluring information. Regardless of how much you buy into 40s or cones, it’s a fun experiment in comparisons.

Year Name H W 40 Press Vert Leap B Jump Shuttle 3Cone
2007 Marshawn Lynch 71 215 4.46 20 35.5 125 4.58 7.09
2005 Darren Sproles 66 187 4.47 23 33 105 3.96 6.96
2011 Shane Vereen 70 210 4.49 31 34 115 4.28 6.95
2009 Knowshon Moreno 71 217 4.5 25 35.5 115 4.27 6.84
2010 Toby Gerhart 73 231 4.5 22 38 118 4.25 6.94
2013 Giovani Bernard 68 202 4.53 19 33.5 122 4.12 6.91
2007 Ahmad Bradshaw 70 198 4.55 34 112 4.09 6.7
2013 Eddie Lacy 73 220 4.55  –


Not everyone runs their best 40 at the combine (and I have not earned admission into The U of Draftnik yet), but at 231lbs, Gerhart shares company with notable small guys, shifty backs, and situational/3rd down players, as well as a handful of “pounders” that while similar in score, weigh a large infant-to-toddler less than him. He is the heaviest of the bunch, yet performed at or near the top in vertical leap, broad jump, and 3 cone drills while maintaining a respectable (but not flashy) 40 time.

Gerhart was drafted in 2010 by Minnesota in the second round (#4 RB off the board), and spent the next four seasons under NFL great AP/All Day/Superman, which is great for erudition, but terrible for action.

Year Att Yds TD Y/A Rec Yds Y/R TD
2010 81 322 1 4 21 167 8 0
2011 109 531 1 4.9 23 190 8.3 3
2012 50 169 1 3.4 20 155 7.8 0
2013 36 283 2 7.9 13 88 6.8 0
Career 276 1305 5 4.7 77 600 7.8 3


The first thing about Gerhart’s numbers that jumps out are his Yards-per-Attempt (Y/A). Over four seasons (2013 was admittedly weak for attempts) he’s averaged 4.7 yards-per-attempt. Not a pedestrian number, as it averages out to about the 12th best RB in Y/A over the last 4 years.

The next stat that “makes it move” is Gerhart’s receptions. With involvement in only 28% of Minnesota’s offensive snaps through four seasons, Gerhart managed to cross 20 receptions three times. Those numbers are knocking on the door of Peterson, Lynch, and Mathews territory; and crossing the line of Gores and Morris’, all of which are primary backs in their respective offenses. With little competition from the current sel2976 Vikings PackersJacksonville backfield, Gerhart could easily be seen as a three-down-back.

As tantalizing as that all is, there is a very big BUT hampering the excitement of things to come – The Jacksonville Jaguars. Finishing 31st in rushing, the Jags lacked talent up front, were converting to a new zone-blocking scheme, and suffered some crippling injuries to make matters worse.

In 2013, the Jacksonville O-line finished at, or near, the bottom in rush blocking rankings. Conversely, the Vikings ranked as a top tier unit. In 2013, the Jaguars realized their impending weakness and wisely spent the #2 overall pick on OT Luke Joeckel. Unfortunately, Joeckel was lost for the season before he could help. Jacksonville somewhat salvaged their poor luck by slowly stabilizing the talent on their “Red Rover” line, and found a balance in their zone blocking brought in by Bradley.

In 2014, Jacksonville made early free agency news with the signing of LG Zane Beadles, formerly of the Denver Broncos. Beadle has been a consistent blocker (although down in 2013), and will solidify the blind side with LT Luke Joeckel. They still have a gap at center due to Brad Meester’s retirement after 14 years with the Jags, but as of this writing the Jags are reportedly about $40 million under cap and have the ability to make it rain in free agency and shore up areas of need.

Gerhart’s role in a new offense raised some questions. His contract was an initial indicator of how Jacksonville felt about him ($4.5 million guaranteed), but a resounding high-five occurred when Head Coach Gus Bradley was quoted with an indication that Gerhart would receive 15-20 touches a game, which is plenty to make an impact.

Final take – Gerhart is clearly a baller, with both the stats and skills to be considered a relevant primary back in the National Football League. The landing spot could have been better, but it appears the volume will exist. I feel Gerhart will find initial success on a roster as an RB2, with potential to creep higher in 2015-16 if Jacksonville continues to work on deficits.


Leave a Reply

2014 Fantasy Football

2014 Fantasy Running Back Review

  The fantasy football offseason is slowly moving along with shuttle runs, forty times, and broad jumps just around the corner. To help pass time over the cold , cold winter months, your pals at The Fake Football will be providing mountains of fantasy coverage on the upcoming season. But before ...


2014 Fantasy Quarterback Review

  Welcome, fake footballers. By this early point in the offseason, you have probably dusted and shined your new league championship trophy for the 73rd time, and hopefully you’ve spent most of January crafting winning DFS lineups with the help of the wizardry that is our weekly DFS cheat sheet. Now, Danny Tanner, ...


Conference Championship DFS: It’s A Trap!

  Check out The Fake Football’s Conference Championship DFS Cheat Sheet!   One last trap for one last weekend of NFL DFS. Some would probably argue that just playing this slate is the trap. Ignoring that possibility, we have two great games on tap Sunday. Four great offenses (all top 10 except NE ...