The Matchup Machine: Week 2 September 12, 2013  |  Scott Watson

Do you smell that?  The Matchup Machine is whipping up a fresh batch of new numbers to enjoy.  Piping hot Week 1 data was sprinkled in with stats from the 2012 Fantasy Playoffs (Weeks 14-16) to create the delicious Matchup Rankings listed at the end of this tasty column.  Friendly reminder: after consuming, please wait 30 minutes before swimming.

New Orleans @ Tampa Bay

• This week could be the Jimmy Graham show.  We all witnessed time travel last week, when Tampa turned back the clock for Kellen Winslow.  In the four weeks included in the Matchup Machine, Tampa gave up a TD to a TE each week.  Opposing QBs completed 82% of their passes to TEs, posting a QB rating north of 150.  Hopefully you aren’t facing Graham this week.

• Someone lower on your radar than Graham, but still worth a potential start is Josh Freeman.  In the four Matchup Machine Weeks, offenses facing New Orleans have only run the ball 28% of the time and passed for more than 300 yards three times.  The last time these two teams met, Freemen threw four picks, but the time before that (in Tampa) he threw three TDs and 400 yards.  Freeman did not look great against the Jets, but the Jets allowed just one 300-yard passer in all of 2012 (Brady).  If you’re hard pressed for a QB, Freeman may work out.

NY Jets @ New England

• Speaking of Brady, the Matchup Machine has Tom Brady ranked quite low this week and in light of his shrinking arsenal, it’s hard to disagree. But some players just have a team’s number.  And Tom Brady definitely has the New York Jets’ number.  Over the past two years, the New York Jets defense has allowed an opposing QB to throw for 300+ yards just four times.  Three of those times it was Tom Brady tossing the pigskin.  Weapons or not, bench him at your own peril.

• Despite his strong outing last week, Kellen Winslow will not have it so easy in Week 2.  As we saw above, Tampa has not defended the TE position very well and Winslow benefited big time.  New England, on the other hand, has allowed an average of just 4 catches for 34 yards to opposing TEs during the four Matchup Machine weeks.

San Francisco @ Seattle

• Last year, non-Seattle running backs averaged just 3.2 YPC against San Francisco (which is better than what Green Bay RBs got last week).  But Seattle is special, they have Marshawn Lynch.  In the two games last year, Lynch averaged 4.8 YPC and posted over 100 rushing yards each time.  Keep Lynch in your lineup.

• Anquan Boldin absolutely torched the Green Bay secondary last week.  In the 2012 Fantasy Playoffs, Green Bay allowed an average of 115 yards on 10 catches to opposing WRs, so Boldin’s 13 catches and 208 yards were not exactly expected.  Similarly, Seattle has allowed just 10 catches for 107 yards to opposing WRs over the four Matchup Machine weeks.  As much as I like Seattle at home, I can’t bench Boldin this week.

Pittsburgh @ Cincinnati

• Hopefully this does not ruin your week, but if you have any piece of the Pittsburgh running game, they should be on your bench.  Over the last four Matchup Machine weeks, Cincinnati is allowing less than 2.8 YPC.  With their current stable of runners, it’s doubtful Pittsburgh will best that number.  This is probably a week where Pittsburgh will be forced to rely on Ben Roethlisberger.  But coming off a five sack game, missing a center, and facing a bitter Jerome Harrison…don’t be surprised if the Cincinnati Defense outscores Big Ben.

• Despite running the ball a league leading 67% of the time last week, Tennessee RBs managed just 2.9 YPC against Pittsburgh.  Pittsburgh was stout against the run during the 2012 Fantasy Playoffs as well, allowing just 3.0 YPC to opposing RBs.  That being said, I wouldn’t trust BenJarvus Green-Ellis or Giovani Bernard to run well this week.

16 Responses

  1. Conor says:

    I dont understand how this matchup chart works…

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi Conor – Sorry, I didn’t see your question until now. As far as the chart goes….the higher the number, the better the matchup. The numbers are calculated based on what this week’s opponent has allowed to that particular position in the past. Hope that helps!

  2. Taylor says:

    Scott, thank you for the response. I took your advice. Thank you very much! Edelman would of had a better game if it weren’t for the holding call. Thank you again for te response and keep up the solid work

  3. Tom says:

    I need a Flex in a PPR:
    James Jones
    Chris Givens
    Julius Thomas

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi Tom – thanks for your question…this is a tough one. They are all kind of feast or famine guys, aren’t they? The Giants gave up a big game to Witten last week…so I may lean towards him. Good luck!

  4. Vincent says:

    I have 3 spots (1 WR/ 1 TE/ 1 Flex RB/WR/TE) in a PPR for :
    Cecil shorts
    Brian Hartline
    Chris givens
    David Wilson
    Greg Olsen
    Jared Cook

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi Vincent – thanks for you question….I like Shorts, Wilson and Cook. Good luck!

      • vincent says:

        Thank you for your quick response. I will follow your lead and hope Wilson and Hartline don’t repeat last week’s performance.
        I’ll report back on monday!

  5. chains says:

    Ppr…Murray, bowe, or cook?

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi chains – Thanks for your question…I’d roll with Murray. I feel like he will be more involved in the offense than the other two. Good luck!

  6. DiRo says:

    Need to start 2 guys; Ty Hilton, D Richardson, Thompkins, Gio Bernard.

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi DiRo – thanks for your question. I’d start Hilton and Thompkins. Gio and D-Rich have tough matchups this week and Indy already stated they need to get Hilton more involved, while Thompkins is one of the few remaining weapons on offense. Good luck!

  7. Taylor says:

    Matchup advice: I have TEs Vernon Davis and Jordan Cameron. I also just picked up Edelman. Who would you start at TE and the Flex? As of now, I have Cameron at TE (great matchup with Gordon still out) and Edelamn at the flex. Your thoughts?

    • porterhouse says:

      twin te’s for sure- if you can.. it’s still undecided if edelman or thompkins is going to be double teamed tonight so why not go with the two TE’s that are going to def part of their respective teams game plan. also, the hawks are not going to let boldin go off again which leaves vdavis to go mental. my 2 cents

    • Scott Watson says:

      Hi Taylor – Thanks for your question. You have three good options so what ever you decide, I think you will be in good shape. But I am going to disagree with porterhouse and actually recommend Edelman and Cameron. We both agree on Cameron. Great game last week, and Baltimore gave up a lot to TEs last week. As for Edeleman, Evan Silva tweeted that Edelman plays mostly in the slot, and the Jets top CB (Cromartie) plays outside. I think Brady leans on him big time tonite – especially good for PPR leagues. Good luck!

Leave a Reply


2014 Scoring Settings Analysis – QB

  Analyzing the differences in fantasy football player values between different scoring setups has long been a fascination of mine.  Longtime readers of might remember installments of this series from 2011, 2012, or my breakdown from the 2013 preseason specific to passing touchdown values.  If you weren’t around for those, ...


Game Flowbotics – Week 16

  Do you have what it takes to be a champion of fake football? This is the week you will find out. Find consolation in the fact that even if you fail in your fantasy finals match-up, you can still be the champion of other things, like doing the dishes or ...


Game Flowbotics – Week 12

  Not many, myself included, expected an Oakland victory on Thursday night, but either Latavius Murray really liked Interstellar or he’s secretly a fan of Welsh poetry. He couldn’t, wouldn’t, and didn’t go gentle into that good night, at least not before ripping off 112 yards for 2 touchdowns on 4 ...