Fantasy Equity Score: Eli Manning And Top Quarterbacks July 10, 2015  |  Chet



Mock Draft Simulator | Draft Analyzer | Cheat Sheet Creator  | Draft AssistantAuction Calculator


Last year was a good year for quarterback fantasy equity scores. Our median and high prospects for the first 30 signal callers off the draft board pointed to a handful of guys who could not only serve as useful streamers — matchups plays — but as every-week options.

And that’s the point of streaming: to invest very little in the position, stumble upon a gem and suck the equity out of said gem. Don’t Google that.

Equity scores pointed a flaming red arrow at Russell Wilson, the 15th quarterback off 2014 draft boards, as a major equity opportunity. And Wilson delivered, as his unsustainable rushing production launched him into fantasy’s top-3 signal callers. Equity scores said that Andrew Luck, the fourth quarterback drafted, had No. 1 quarterback in his range of outcomes. Equity analysis also pointed to Drew Brees and Matthew Stafford — especially Stafford — as guys who were being over-drafted.

Equity scores had good things to say about Nick Foles’ prospects too, but we don’t talk about that at the dinner table.

It’s critically important, before we jump into these top quarterback equity scores, that everyone understands that this is not “the year” to go big on quarterbacks. That holds true every season, no matter what, in standard scoring formats.

My Living The Stream co-host and prolific fantasy scribe JJ Zachariason reminded us of why early-round quarterback advocates are always wrong, though fantasy footballers shouldn’t wait until the very late rounds to draft a quarterback just because. Everyone — everyone — is a value sometimes. Let’s review.

While quarterback is the single-most important position on a football field, it’s not in fantasy. This supply and demand way of thinking shows just that – there’s a ripple effect that spreads to so many areas of fantasy football because the demand for the quarterback position is so inherently small. … The reason the late-round quarterback strategy is a thing is because it’s based on what happens in nearly every single draft. When you have an outlier, things can change. But that’s the case with anything you do. Just remember that this isn’t a game a chicken – this is a game of value.

Even elite quarterbacks have limited “useable” weeks — that is, weeks in which they finish as a top-12 signal caller. The position remains imminently replaceable, as more than 40 quarterbacks have posted at least one top-12 fantasy performance in each of the past three seasons. An incredible 27 quarterbacks had four or more top-12 finishes in 2014. That’s not inconsiderable.

I sympathize with fantasy football’s set-it-and-forget-it crowd. Not everyone gets a full-on endorphin rush every time they dive into the waiver wire and snatch a great streaming option for Sunday’s games. Not everyone can — or wants to — invest hours every Monday and Tuesday making waiver wire decisions that twist the gut.

There are set-it-and-forget-it options among the equity scores listed below. And not every one is near the top.


Player ADP Median equity score High equity score
Andrew Luck QB1 -1 (QB2) 0 (QB1)
Aaron Rodgers QB2 0 (QB2) 1 (QB1)
Peyton Manning QB3 -4 (QB7) 1 (QB2)
Russell Wilson QB4 -2 (QB6) 0 (QB4)
Drew Brees QB5 -2 (QB7) 2 (QB3)
Ben Roethlisberger QB6 -3 (QB9) 0 (QB6)
Cam Newton QB7 0 (QB7) 2 (QB5)
Matt Ryan QB8 -2 (QB10) 1 (QB7)
Tony Romo QB9 2 (QB7) 6 (QB3)
Tom Brady QB10 1 (QB9) 6 (QB4)
Matthew Stafford QB11 -3 (QB14) 2 (QB9)
Eli Manning QB12 3 (QB9) 9 (QB3)


*  No quarterback had more top-5 fantasy weeks than Eli Manning did during the 2014 season’s final nine weeks. It’s no secret as to why Eli put up gaudy numbers during most of the season’s second half. It was, quite simply, the OBJ Effect. Using Eli was an arbitrage play on Odell Beckham, Jr., during his unholy run of dominance. Even if Beckham’s production slides a bit in 2015 — and it probably will — he’ll remain a boon for Eli like we haven’t seen since Calvin Johnson made Stafford elite during Megatron’s prime. Eli’s ADP has risen since the dark days of spring, but he remains a value play as the 12th signal caller off the board. Eli still threw a very Eli-like nine picks during the incredible OBJ stretch run, but he also threw for more yards than anyone else during the season’s second half, averaging a tidy 315.7 yards per contest (and 1.7 touchdowns). Eli also had massive volume on his side, as New York went from an offense that passed 54 percent of the time to 62 percent of plays, per The Fake Football writer Rich Hribar. We shouldn’t overlook off-season reports about Eli becoming more comfortable with new offensive coordinator Ben McAdoo’s system as the season wore on. It’s a narrative, but I think it’s important. You have to pay up for OBJ, but there are a handful of Giants who could be draft day steals thanks to Beckham’s presence, including the guy tossing him the ball. I can’t think of a reason to invest in Roethlisberger, Ryan, Newton, or Brady when I can draft a chunk of OBJ’s production in the middle of the ninth round. Let’s not forget that Eli wasn’t exactly horrid before OBJ’s explosion.


Screen shot 2015-07-09 at 4.57.53 PM


*  Tom Brady‘s prospects hinge on his early-season suspension status, of course. We knew headed into 2014 that Brady has and will be an entirely different fantasy producer with Rob Gronkowski in the lineup. Brady goes for 300.2 yards and 2.2 touchdowns per game when Gronk suits up, and 252 yards and 1.6 scores when his monster tight end is out of the New England lineup. Brady also throws a lot more interceptions without Gronk. I hesitate to say Brady is an equity steal at his current ADP, though that high projection is tough to pass on if you — for some reason — need an elite quarterback on your fantasy squad. Probably Brady’s equity will vanish if his suspension is lifted.


*  Stop drafting Matthew Stafford as a top fantasy quarterback. Just stop.


*  Tony Romo‘s appeal comes with the hope that Dallas offensive coordinator Scott Linehan will go back to his pass-happy ways after grinding it out on the ground with DeMarco Murray in 2014. Romo’s meager 29 pass attempts per game in 2014 are set to rise. That much is clear. Twenty-three quarterbacks last season attempted more passes than Romo, who played 15 games. Romo has never been an incredibly efficient passer (from a per-drop back perspective) so that sort of volume spike is central to his chances to hitting that high equity score. It’s worth noting that Romo has traditionally torn apart bottom-half pass defenses, and his 2015 schedule isn’t exactly discouraging.


*  None of Russell Wilson‘s upside was incorporated into his 2014 ADP. He was being drafted like the solid if unspectacular fantasy producer he was in 2013. His role in the Seahawks’ offense was set to change, however, as coaches gave more slack to their signal caller. He delivered, outscoring Peyton Manning, who was drafted seven rounds before Wilson. Wilson’s ADP shows us that the secret is out and there will be no more draft day value for the guy who might just go play baseball if he doesn’t get that cash-money. While finding a quarterback who racks up fantasy points on the ground is a great strategy for late-round quarterback disciples, Wilson’s ground production should make us wary this summer. Rich Hribar pointed out in May that 36.7 percent of Wilson’s fantasy points came via the run — a rare feat in fantasy football. Jimmy Graham’s presence may buoy Wilson’s production in 2015, but as Hribar warns: “You should be treating his rushing output as fantasy frosting instead of banking on another historical season.” I’ll pass on Wilson in 2015.


4 Responses

  1. Jon says:

    Surprising to see Big Ben at best at #6 and most likely worse. Defense will be in shambles and will have to score a lot of points all season long. Plus with the emergence of Bryant, Wheaton still there, plus Bell receiving receptions and the dad runner Heath Miller. Thoughts?

  2. Mr. Mustache says:

    Matt, Eli has already won 2 super bowls. What has Stafford done?

  3. Edg22 says:

    Context is important with Eli Manning ‘s nine ints during that time. Five came in one game when his Oline collapsed. Charles Brown and John Jerry were protecting his right side. An unmitigated disaster especially with a player like Manning who cares nothing about his stats.

    And one pet peeve with regards to the so called OBJ effect on Eli. OBJ benefitted just as much from having Eli as his QB. You mention Stafford and Megatron. Here’s the difference between Eli and Stafford. Give Stafford an elite weapon and he can’t even get to the playoffs. Give one to Eli and he wins SBs.

    • Matt says:

      LOL, so Eli is going to win a superbowl this year because OBJ is there? Let’s pump the brakes a little on Eli being much better than Stafford.

Leave a Reply

2015 Fantasy Football

The Hail Mary (NFL DFS): Divisional Playoffs WEEKEND UPDATE

  The Huddle – Opening Statement There will be no “My Guys” section as you can plainly see my rankings. The top few guys are “my guys”, the bottom guys are…um, not. New information and thoughts will be in bolded italics. Welcome to the Playoff – Divisional Round Hail Mary. This is ...


Divisional Round DFS Cheat Sheet (UPDATED)

  Welcome to The Fake Football DFS Cheat Sheet for the Divisional Round! . With the help of our resident DFS Gurus Chet Gresham, Ian Goldsmith and Doug Shain, we have put together a comprehensive NFL DFS Cheat Sheet with matchup stats, analysis, picks, sample lineups and lineup configuration advice. We have picks ...


The Hail Mary (NFL DFS): Divisional Playoffs FIRST LOOK

    The Huddle – Opening Statement Welcome to the Playoff – Divisional Round Hail Mary. This is going to be a REALLY abbreviated version of the Hail Mary with only 4 games on the schedule. I’m going to do the article a little differently this week since there are so few ...